I like these little booties!Warmth: keeps my toes toasty for hours in temps in the 30's. I still need a warmer pair for colder days but these will do just fine for traditional NJ winter temps especially if you're not spending a lot of time outdoors.Support: the soles are thick enough to stand and walk in for long periods of time (no breaking in necessary). If you have high arches like I do you may want to use an insert but I find them reasonably comfortable as is.Size: these booties run true to size. I am a size 6, bought a 6, and wear them both with and without inserts, with and without thick socks.Water resistance: I haven't worn them in the rain or snow yet. When I do I'll update my review. I'm apprehensive because the material doesn't seem weatherproof but we will see.Lately everything I buy from Amazon sucks so I'm really happy I found these cute little booties. Highly recommend!*UPDATES Nov. 2021**Warmth: wear warm socks if you're going to be outside for awhile if temps are in the 30's or below. Because the booties have a large gap around your ankle, your feet will be exposed to the elements. It's the style so not unexpected. But still, be aware, especially if you're sitting around like in front of a campfire - the heat from the fire won't be enough. That being said, I've been fine walking around.*Water resistence: I still haven't worn the booties in deep snow or pouring rain so I have no idea how they fare. I've stepped in puddles though - no leaks.*Treads: nothing notable to report, which I guess is a good thing. I'd probably remember if they were bad on ice.*Cleaning: I thought the white soles would get filthy and be impossible to clean. I was wrong! Dirt and rock salt dust just swipes off with a lysol wipe/paper towel. They still look new a year later!*Still 5 stars! Believe me I'm as shocked as you are. To those reading this review in November 2021, fingers crossed this Amazon listing is legit and you get the real booties. They're a great purchase - well worth the price.